題:
我應該向研究生錄取委員會解釋為什麼我比大多數準博士生大嗎?
Vafa Khalighi
2014-11-03 18:55:24 UTC
view on stackexchange narkive permalink

Firstly, I know that there are plenty of questions here like this one but hopefully this is not a duplicate.

I was born and grown up in Iran and belong to a religious minority (Bahai faith). As you know Bahais are not allowed to attend universities in Iran because of their faith. I was no exception and so could not study at university because of my religious beliefs. Between the age of 18 (when I finished my highschool in Iran) and 24, I worked as a construction laborer. At the age of 24, I together with my family (my parents and sister) travelled to Turkey and became refugees in UNHCR and two years later UNHCR sent us to Australia. I studied English for two years and after that I repeated year 11 and 12 because Australian universities did not accept my Iranian qualifications. At age 30, I started my undergraduate studies in Bachelor of Electrical Engineering and I will graduate very soon. I am now 35 years of age and would like to apply to be a PhD student in the first 5 or 10 top engineering schools in the world. I have maintained a GPA of 6.9, a WAM of 93 and was on Dean's merit list every year except the first year of my undergraduate studies. There is a possibility that I also get university medal but that is not certain yet.

Should I explain these details to the graduate admission committee explaining why I started my undergraduate studies very late at the age of 30? and what I was doing before that?

不,您一點都沒有讓我感到厭煩。您的問題的第二段感動了我。我認為您可以將其放入目的聲明或求職信中。我認為這將是有益和足夠的。
@scaaahu:感謝您的友好評論。然後,我將簡要介紹我在目的聲明中描述的內容。
這是一個很好的故事,可以說明您學習的動機。 *但是您還不算老。
我會補充說,根據字段的不同,您的某些或大多數同齡人可能比您預期的年齡大。我在25歲時進入了藝術碩士課程,是該課程中最年輕的人之一。申請時感覺有點老,因為我剛滿19歲就開始上大學,並花了6年時間。我比大多數本科生朋友大1-3歲。我這個年齡以下的碩士生很少。多數人在20多歲到30多歲之間,而我們在40多歲,50多歲和60多歲時又招收了幾名學生。我懷疑博士課程的年齡會更加廣泛。
您的年齡可能不會對您不利。實際上,以我的經驗來看,年長的研究生通常更具有動力和科學上的成熟。我認為這也適用於您的情況。祝好運!
這感動了我。祝您和所有* Bahais一切順利
您的GPA需要一些解釋,這似乎是非標準的。至少說“可能的y.0的6.9”。
我曾經和一位女士一起工作,一位女士在她40多歲的時候辭職並獲得博士學位。她剛從高中畢業的女兒在獲得博士學位時為她提供了支持。因此,年齡較大的博士生絕對不是聞所未聞的...
在我這一天,我們有一些傑出的中國學者在偉大的文藝復興時期被送往農村-他們失去了十年從事奴隸制工作的時間,並且有更多的時間移民。你還不算老
-1
“由於他們的信仰,不允許巴哈教徒在大學學習”。您能解釋一下伊朗和國外數十個巴哈教徒如何在各個學科獲得這些學位嗎?
您已經收到了很多回應,指出您應該包括自己的故事。我想補充一下我的經歷:由於戰爭,我上大學有些延遲,每當我申請學術職位或助學金時,人們都會對此表示同情。擁有這樣的生活背景表明您有決心,而且決心在學術界很重要,因為進行研究時需要大量的知識。
這是一個很棒的故事,至少在某些學校中,這實際上可以為您帶來好處。確保在招生文章中包括以上所有內容。我沒有很好的藉口,來自西方國家,但我的博士學位僅在30歲時開始;我記得最年長的同班同學在第一年是42歲(她並不孤單:第一年晚了30年)。我女友的一位教授輟學了10年,如今已成名,並在常春藤任教。您表現出堅韌不拔的精神,對博士而言,無所不包。祝你好運!
您應該將故事放入應用程序中。入學後,您將面臨更大的挑戰,這就是您和其他同學之間的年齡差異。美國大學的大多數學生都是18-22歲。在研究生和博士課程中,許多人年齡在22-28歲之間。這些人將在5到6年內每天與您見面並互動。您不可能向所有人解釋您的故事,無論他們多麼友善和開明,他們中的一些人都會根據您的年齡而歧視您。
剛剛註冊以支持這個問題。祝好運。
克服生活障礙的決心和毅力將使您比年輕的學生更有能力。
@user23872根據伊朗憲法,所有亞伯拉罕宗教的人都是平等的(很可能是瓦哈比人和巴哈伊人除外,但這不在憲法中),而且所有非穆斯林人民的人權都必須得到政府的尊重。但是現實中發生的是另一回事,它取決於許多其他因素。關於您的問題,這很可能是因為沒有人在註冊大學時真正地審查過人們。他們可能沒有在那裡宣布自己的宗教信仰。
五 答案:
Maarten Buis
2014-11-03 19:59:36 UTC
view on stackexchange narkive permalink

Such information would be relevant. The real trick would be to keep such a paragraph short and to the point. As such the question would be a good draft of such a section. I have two comments:

I would not start the second sentence with "as you know". If a committee member did not know, you make her or him feel ignorant. It is good to avoid invoking negative emotions in such a letter. Especially since leaving that part out does not change the meaning of the sentence.

It was not clear from the text whether it was the Bahai faith that prohibited it's members from going to university or whether it was the Iranian government that prohibited people with the Bahai religion to enter university.

感謝您的回复。伊朗政府禁止擁有巴哈伊教徒的人上大學。
-1
Bob Brown
2014-11-03 20:02:11 UTC
view on stackexchange narkive permalink

我希望scaaahu可以在評論中回答該評論,以便我可以對其進行投票。

也許它可以幫助您了解我開始了博士學位。當時年僅56歲。它沒有進入前十名大學,但我也不為自己的母校感到羞恥。招生委員會對研究和教學的潛力感興趣。顯示這些內容,並在您的背景下獲得報價。

在scaaahu所建議的求職信或目的陳述中,請務必提供非常簡短的解釋。它不必像您在此處發布的內容那樣廣泛。只需向正在思考的委員會成員講話,“我想知道為什麼……?”簡單地說:“我的信徒不允許在我的祖國伊朗上大學,所以我起步較晚。”

感謝您的回复。你的好話激勵了我一大堆。
我在您的來信或目標陳述中建議的細節最少。我注意到那些提出更多細節的人比我擁有更多的學術經驗。
Pete L. Clark
2014-11-03 23:03:28 UTC
view on stackexchange narkive permalink

我建議您將您提供給我們的信息放入博士學位申請的目的聲明中。至少對於美國式的目的聲明(通常為兩頁左右),我不建議簡述您告訴我們的故事。相反,我同意@scaaahu的觀點,您的故事極具說服力,遠比通常在此類陳述中閱讀的故事更令人信服。在多年的逆境中取得了學術上的成功:這真棒。如果我在我的程序(數學,UGA)的博士學位申請中看到了這一點,那麼我將通過您的聲明,供整個招生委員會閱讀。如果您的申請書的其他部分具有相當的競爭力,那麼我會竭盡全力地爭取您的錄取。您有很多值得驕傲的地方,並且肯定會激發許多其他人的靈感。學術界需要像你這樣的人。

Scott Seidman
2014-11-04 04:08:41 UTC
view on stackexchange narkive permalink

DEFINITELY include information on what you describe. More importantly, though, you are a more mature student, and at your age you should show a very solid understanding of why you need a PhD to pursue your career goals.

"Atypical" students can be great additions for departments, but if I were the one doing the choosing, I would be looking for more than your history, academic or otherwise -- I'd be looking to see whether you understand why you want the degree, and what you intend to do with it. Give your admissions committee your whole picture.

您的最後一段可以幫我嗎?我想要博士學位,是因為我想成為一名學者,因為我想解決電氣工程中的開放性問題,因為我想幫助其他人。夠了還是我需要更好的理由?
這是一個非常不同的問題。除了“我想成為一名學者以外,其他問題都是由工程師完成的,他們通常不需要在學位後花五到六年的時間就可以完成工作。
Tom Au
2014-11-05 03:15:03 UTC
view on stackexchange narkive permalink

There are some people that probably should "dodge" this issue. You are NOT one of them. So an explanation will help you, with very little risk.

You come from what most Western institutions would consider a "disadvantaged" background. You have succeeded in spite of that fact. You got a later start in university life because you got a lot of life experience in what we Americans would call "the school of hard knocks." That's very much to your credit. Most western universities would give a positive weight to "maturity" and sense of purpose in evaluating an application. You have both.

The kind of person who might have something to fear regarding age is someone from a (probably) rich family who had a "wasted" (or misspent) youth. You are not that person.



該問答將自動從英語翻譯而來。原始內容可在stackexchange上找到,我們感謝它分發的cc by-sa 3.0許可。
Loading...